PCTG Consumer Complaint Report Record ID#: 1448635362

Date of Report Submission: 11/27/15

Complaint Comments:

Grange supervisor Richard Lukotch was contacted via email for the following reasons: Paint Capped at $425.00 Refusal to pay a required operation – Prime, Feather and Block. Refusal to pay for cleaning exterior of vehicle. Manually overridden deductions of 2.0 hours of refinish labor. Refusal to pay tint time in the refinish operation. Short paid the required time to sand and polish ¾ of the freshly refinished vehicle. Mr. Lukotch responded in writing that his company was following industry standards and our request was in error. I am asking your department to review the business practices of Grange Insurance Company. This is a blatant theft of a service provided. I had attached a copy from their own estimating system stating Prime, Feather and Block is a required Refinish operation. There was over 10.0 hours of body repairs and we were shorted the allotted time needed to properly repair this vehicle. They also capped the paint materials at a mere $425 to paint ¾ of the vehicle. Refusal to pay us to clean the exterior is another example of a theft of service. Mr. Lukotch’s response was very unprofessional and failed to call after we requested it in writing. We have numerous examples of getting compensated for the required operations from insurance companies. So Mr. Lukotch’s statement is fictitious. I have attached a copy of procedure in writing from Granges estimating system. This will provide an unbiased example of Granges criminal intent to steal a service required and provided. Capping paint materials is another systematic example of theft as the cost to repair exceeded the reimbursement paid out. Please investigate their unfair business practice as it pertains our commonwealth law. Feel free to contact me with any questions and thank you in advance for protecting our consumer’s rights.

Itemized List of Submitted Complaints
Violation of Unfair Ins. Practices Act Title 40
Violation of Unfair Claims Settlement PA Code Title 31
Violation of Automotive Industry Trade Practices Title 37
Inaccurate description of repairs
Arbitrary Capping & Underpayment

Consumer Information

Name:

Address:

City:

State:

Zip:

Daytime Phone:

Evening Phone:

Repair Facility Information

Repair Facility: Alan's Collision Center

State Appraiser License: 209533

Shop Representative: Jim PFau

Address: 601 Red Lion rd

City: Phila

State: Pa

Zip: 19115

Phone: 215-677-7773

Insurance Information

Insurance Company: Grange Insurance

Claim Number: APV001952542-001-1

Insurance Company Representative: Richard Lukotch

Date of Loss:

Appraiser License Number: Supervisor

Insurance Company Phone: 800-303-9141

Legislator Information

Consumer Legislative Representative: Murt , Thomas P. (R) District 152

Consumer Senator: Rafferty, John C. (R) District 44

Repair Facility Legislative Representative: Murt , Thomas P. (R) District 152

Repair Facility Senator: Rafferty, John C. (R) District 44