PCTG Consumer Complaint Report Record ID#: 1153172195

Date of Report Submission: 07/17/06

Complaint Comments:

SHOP CONTACTED TRAVELER SUPPLEMENT DESK 7-14-06 REQUESTING SUPPLEMENT. SHOP WAS TOLD BY DALE SMITH TO FORWARD REQUEST BY FAX AND PICTURES BY EMAIL TO HIM FOR HIS REVIEW. SHOP COMPLIED AS REQUESTED. SHOP RELEASED VEHICLE IN GOOD FAITH TO OWNER HAVING NOT HEARED FROM MR. SMITH. WHEN THE SHOP CALLED MR. SMITH 7 17 06 FOR A EXPLANATION ON HIS WHAT WE FELT WAS A SHORT SUPPLEMENT MR. SMITH TOLD THE SHOP HE CAN ONLY WRITE WHAT IS IN HIS DATA BASE. HE STATED WE WERE NICKLE/DIME-ING HIM AND HE WRITES SUPPLEMENTS FOR OTHER SHOPS AND THEY ARE ACCEPTED AS HE WRITES THEM. HE TOLD ME TO CALL THE ORIGINAL ADJUSTER IF I WANTED TO BE PAID FOR WHAT WE DID ALSO STATING "HE DOES NOT NEED THIS" AND HUNG UP THE PHONE. ITEMS SHOP REQUESTED TO BE PAID IN FULL FOR AND NOT ARE: CLEAN FOR DELIVERY SHORT $7.00, COLOR SAND AND BUFF SHORT $37.00, BACK TAPE EDGES SHORT $25, SEAM SEALER SHORT $4.00. TOTAL $73.00 PLUS $4.38 SALES TAX = $77.38. SHOP FEELS MR. SMITH AS A LICENSED APPRAISER SHOULD HAVE CONTACTED THE SHOP TO REVIEW ITEMS HE WAS NOT PAYING TO COME TO A AGREED PRICE OF THE SUPPLEMENT.

Itemized List of Submitted Complaints
Unprofessional Behavior
Arbitrary Capping & Underpayment

Consumer Information

Name:

Address:

City:

State:

Zip:

Daytime Phone:

Evening Phone:

Repair Facility Information

Repair Facility: North Star Automotive

State Appraiser License: 131559

Shop Representative: KEITH A STEPHENS

Address: 4230 FRITCH DRIVE

City: BETHLEHEM

State: PA

Zip: 18020

Phone: 610 865 9646

Insurance Information

Insurance Company: TRAVELERS

Claim Number: URM0316001

Insurance Company Representative: DALE SMITH

Date of Loss: 04-25-06

Appraiser License Number: 131740

Insurance Company Phone: 6103713945

Legislator Information

Consumer Legislative Representative: N/A

Consumer Senator: N/A

Repair Facility Legislative Representative: Freeman, Robert L. (D) - District 136

Repair Facility Senator: Boscola , Lisa M. (D) - District 18